In Depth Baby Product Reviews Led by a Pediatrician
We buy all the products we test — no freebies from companies. If you purchase through our links, we may earn a commission, which helps support our testing.

Ameda Purely Yours Review

This is a pump that has been on the market for a long time, but new pumps now have the edge
gearlab tested logo
Ameda Purely Yours Review
Credit: Ameda
Price:  $316 List
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Manufacturer:   Ameda
By Lindsay Smith and Curtis Smith  ⋅  Mar 4, 2014
49
OVERALL
SCORE
  • Efficiency - 30% 5.0
  • Comfort - 20% 4.0
  • Ease of Use - 25% 5.0
  • Portability - 10% 5.0
  • Hygiene - 10% 5.0
  • Accoustics - 5% 6.0

Our Verdict

The Ameda Purely Yours double electric breast pump comes from an innovative company that changed the face of pumping as we know it by creating a pump that many companies eventually mimicked. Although it was once beyond its time, it has now been surpassed by some of the newer pumps on the market. In our opinion, this pump still performed decently, landing right in the middle on every category we tested.
REASONS TO BUY
Reliable
Efficient
Has a battery pack
REASONS TO AVOID
Expensive
Uncomfortable
Poor quality accessories

Our Analysis and Test Results

New Version Update - February 2015
We are now linking to the Ameda Purely Yours Ultra (below left) as the Purely Yours we reviewed (below right) is not readily available. The major difference is that the Ultra includes a faux leather tote bag, an extra set of flanges, and 3 power sources with the inclusion of a car adapter whereas the Purely Yours we reviewed had just the AC adapter and battery power sources.
Ameda Purely Yours Ultra
Ameda Purely Yours Ultra
Components of the Ameda.
Components of the Ameda.

Ameda was started 70 years ago by a Swedish engineer named Einar Egnell. His clever approach to breast pump design soon led to other similar products entering the marketplace. We found this pump to be adequate, but amid mixed user reviews, we were curious to sort things out ourselves.

Performance Comparison



Efficiency


We scored this pump at a 5/10 on efficiency. It produced a comparable amount of milk as some of our other pumps, but not in the same amount of time as our higher scoring pumps. It also took some time to set up and wasn't as intuitive as we would have liked to see and we often found ourselves double-checking the instructions.

Comfort


ameda purely yours - the dials can be tricky to operate consistently.
The dials can be tricky to operate consistently.
Credit: Micah James
The Purely Yours landed low for comfort with a 4/10. The pump does have a dial for suction and strength, but it is hard to be very specific about the settings. We found this pump to create a harsh tug on the breast that was for us, very uncomfortable. Our testers mentioned they could not use this pump multiple times a day and nurse because their nipples were too sore following use. This can also hinder the pump's efficiency because if you're in pain and tense, your milk let down may not happen as quickly.

Ease of Use


This pump landed in the middle for ease of use. The lower score is mainly due to the set up taking a little longer, as well as the amount of time we spent fumbling with the dials. The dials are very hard to control accurately and require a lot of manipulation to get to a desirable suction strength. It also has a unique suction style which requires that you put a lid on the pump adapters prior to connecting them to the tubing.

Portability


ameda purely yours - insulated cooler and tote bag. it was difficult to fit the pump and...
Insulated cooler and tote bag. It was difficult to fit the pump and all accessories into the tote.
Credit: Micah James
This pump was given a 5/10 for portability. It does come with a tote bag and an insulated bag, but the quality of each is not as good as the ones for some of the other pumps we tested. It's also difficult to fit all the parts needed for pumping on-the-go into the tote bag, and if you are a working mother, mornings can be rushed and you need a bag that can fit everything in at once without the hassle of re-organizing!

Hygiene


This pump received a 5 for hygiene. Although it does offer a closed system, which we love, the parts were still more time consuming to take apart and clean and were also difficult to dry completely.

Acoustics


We scored this pump a 6/10 for acoustics as it's just a bit louder than others we tested. Your co-workers will be able to hear this pump as they come down the hallway (which can be a good thing) but it would not be a good pump to use next to your sleeping baby or partner at night.

Best Applications


This pump is meant for a working mom or exclusive pumper. Its double electric design makes it easy to empty both breasts at the same time in a somewhat efficient manner. It also comes with batteries so you can use it when there is no plug available.

Value


This list price for the Ameda Purely Yours is $287 (the Ultra is $300 List), which we feel is much too high for the value you receive. We feel that the Medela Pump In Style Advanced, our Best Value Award winner, out-pumped this unit by far.

Conclusion


Although this pump is effective overall, it just couldn't stand up to the other double electric pumps we tested.

— Lindsay Smith and Curtis Smith
 
Table of Contents

You Might Also Like