| |
| | | | | | | | | | | | | |
| Awards |
 Best Sleepsack |  Best Swaddle for Newborns |  Best Bang for the Buck Sleep Sack |  Best Swaddle for Newborn Hips |  Easiest to Use Swaddle | | | |  Most Versatile Swaddle | | | | | |
| Price |
$109 List Check Price at Amazon | $30 List Check Price at Amazon | $25 List Check Amazon (on sale!) | $25 List Check Amazon (on sale!) | $35 List Check Price at Amazon | $27 List Check Price at Amazon | $30 List Check Price at Amazon | $35 List Check Price at Amazon | $40 List Check Amazon (on sale!) | $60 List Check Price at Amazon | $40 List Check Price at Amazon | $28 List Check Amazon (on sale!) | $30 List Check Amazon (on sale!) | $50 List Check Price at Amazon |
Overall Score  |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| Star Rating |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| Bottom Line |
High quality sleep sack that uses wool to help regulate temperature, but is quite expensive and high maintenance | An escape-proof swaddle that is a bit more time-consuming with lots of wrapping, but is free of snaps, zippers, and Velcro | Lightweight organic cotton sleep sack that has a large age range, but may need to be sized down and may not be good for colder climates | Budget-friendly swaddle with a hip-healthy design, but not as simple to use and the Velcro is loud | Uniquely shaped swaddle is good for arms up sleepers, but does not offer alternate positioning | Soft and stretchy blanket that provides a comfy, tight wrap, but only if you can master the swaddling process | An easy-to-use, versatile swaddle that falls short in comfort and durability | A simple hybrid swaddle perfect for beginners, but the quality is not excellent and the Velcro closure could wake a baby | Soft swaddling and multi-purpose blanket uses excellent materials, but is harder to use than sleep sacks | A great, easy-to-use, tight-fitted wrap, but not well-suited for warm climates or light sleepers | A baby swaddle and sleep sack that accommodates five stages of growth, but has many snaps and zippers to contend with | A simple to use swaddle that allows more freedom for movement but is sized for smaller babies and is not adjustable | An affordable 3-pack of hybrid swaddles that are much lower quality than most other options | A unique, but difficult-to-use transitional product for babies who are out of the swaddling stage, but it is heavy and not breathable |
| Pros |
Large age range, durable, easy size adjustments | Easy to use, Velcro free, quality material | Soft fabric, organic cotton, easy to use | Secure wrap, soft material, hip friendly | User-friendly, soft fabric, 2-way zipper, easy diaper changes | Soft material, snug swaddle, multi-use | Can swaddle arms in or out, 2-way zipper, soft & breathable fabric | Easy to use, reverse zipper, can swaddle arms in or out | Highest quality, breathable and soft material, versatile, large | Secure wrap, intuitive | Expandable sizing, 2-way zipper, easy to use | Impossible to do wrong, 2-way zipper, soft material | Affordable, easy to use for beginners | Very warm, soothing after the swaddle stage, will not come undone |
| Cons |
Expensive, requires special cleaning care | Lots of wrapping, layers might get warm | Very lightweight, runs large | Loud Velcro closure, more steps to swaddle | Doesn't swaddle as tight, less durable | Must learn to swaddle, serged edges may fray | Scratchy Velcro, not escape-proof, not very durable | Loud velcro, lower quality | Harder to use than sleep sacks, difficult to get tight enough | Baby can overheat, loud Velcro | Less comfortable for baby, may be short for 18mo | Runs small, thin fabric, very little leg room, no adjustability | Thin fabric, cheap construction, not very soft | Difficult to dress baby, heavyweight fabric may overheat, not breathable |
| Rating Categories |
Woolino 4 Season Ult... |
Miracle Blanket |
Burt's Bees Baby Bee... |
Ergobaby Swaddler |
Love to Dream UP |
Copper Pearl |
Happiest Baby Sleepea |
HALO SleepSack |
Aden + Anais Classic |
Ollie |
Woombie Grow With Me... |
Summer Infant Swaddl... |
Comfy Cubs Blankets |
Baby Merlin's Magic... |
| Baby Comfort (40%) |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| Ease of Use (40%) |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| Durability (20%) |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| Specifications |
Woolino 4 Season Ult... |
Miracle Blanket |
Burt's Bees Baby Bee... |
Ergobaby Swaddler |
Love to Dream UP |
Copper Pearl |
Happiest Baby Sleepea |
HALO SleepSack |
Aden + Anais Classic |
Ollie |
Woombie Grow With Me... |
Summer Infant Swaddl... |
Comfy Cubs Blankets |
Baby Merlin's Magic... |
| Style |
Sleep Sack |
Swaddle Wrap |
Sleep Sack |
Velcro Swaddle |
Zippered Swaddle |
Traditional Swaddle Blanket |
Zippered Transition Swaddle with Velcro |
Zippered Transition Swaddle with Velcro |
Traditional Swaddle Blanket |
Velcro Transition Swaddle |
Zippered Transition Swaddle |
Zippered Swaddle |
Velcro Swaddle |
Zippered Transitional Sleep Suit |
| Material |
GOTS Certified Organic Cotton with OEKO-TEX Standard 100 Certified Merino Wool Core |
Cotton |
GOTS Certified Organic Cotton |
Cotton |
Cotton and Elastane (Organic Cotton and Bamboo also available) |
Polyester and Rayon |
GOTS Certified Organic Cotton, Elastane, and Polyester |
Cotton |
Cotton Muslin |
OEKO-TEX Standard 100 Certified Polyester and Spandex |
Cotton and Spandex |
Cotton and Spandex |
Cotton |
Cotton Lining with Polyfil Core |
| Zipper Direction |
Two-way |
NA |
Reverse |
NA |
Two-way |
NA |
Two-way |
Reverse |
NA |
NA |
Two-way |
Two-way |
NA |
Regular |
| TOG rating |
NA |
Not Listed |
0.5 |
0.5 |
1.0 |
NA |
0.5 |
1.5 |
NA |
0.8 |
Not Listed |
0.3 |
0.5 |
Not Listed |
| Age Range |
2 Months-4 Years |
0-14 Weeks |
0-18 Months |
0-3 Months |
0-6 Months |
All ages |
0-18 Months |
0-6 Months |
All ages |
0-6 Months |
0-18 Months |
0-2 Months |
0-6 Months |
3-9 Months |
| Available Sizes |
Baby, Toddler |
One Size |
Small, Medium, Large |
One Size |
Newborn, Small, Medium |
46" x 46" |
X-small, Small, Medium, Large, X-Large |
Preemie, Newborn, Small |
47" x 47" |
One Size |
One Size |
One Size |
Small/Med, Large |
Small, Large |
| Washing Instructions |
Machine wash cool. Can be tumble dried on No Heat or Air Dry setting. Hang to dry whenever possible. |
Machine wash cold, tumble dry low |
Machine wash cold, tumble dry on low heat |
Machine wash, tumble dry low |
Machine wash warm gentle cycle, use garment bag. Tumble dry low or line dry out of direct sunlight. |
Machine wash cold, tumble dry on low heat |
Secure arm and leg velcro tabs and close zipper. Machine wash cool or cold with like colors, tumble dry on low heat. |
Close fastener strips before washing. Machine wash with like colors. |
Wash with like colors, do not wash with any thing that could snag (velcro, buttons, snaps) |
Secure all velcro tabs and place in included laundry bag. Machine wash cold on gentle cycle, and tumble dry on low or no heat. |
Machine wash warm, air dry or tumble dry on low heat. |
Machine wash cold gentle cycle, tumble dry low |
Close three tabs before washing. Machine wash cold, gentle cycle, tumble dry on low heat. |
Wash cold on the gentle cycle with like colors. Hang to dry (inside out is faster) |