In Depth Baby Product Reviews Led by a Pediatrician
We buy all the products we test — no freebies from companies. If you purchase through our links, we may earn a commission, which helps support our testing.
By Wendy Schmitz ⋅ Senior Review Editor ⋅ Jan 7, 2025
Analysis and Award Winners
Sometimes, your baby will struggle to sleep soundly or fall asleep. Often, snuggles and soothing from mom or dad are not enough, and an external noise or sound machine for baby can be a huge help. If your little one is struggling to fall asleep or stay asleep a sound machine for babies can help them soothe themselves and stay asleep, even with outside stimuli that might otherwise disrupt their sleep cycle.
We've been testing baby gear since 2012 and started testing sound machines for baby in 2020. We considered over 50 noise makers and purchased 7 impressive sound machines for testing in-house and in the real world. A good sound machine can help babies fall asleep and stay asleep by providing a constant sound in the background that is both soothing and blocks out other sounds to help prevent startling noises from disrupting sleep. We assessed the machines with sleeping babies in mind.
The most impressive sound machine for baby is the VTech Myla The Monkey. This adorable and portable monkey does just enough to keep little ones calm without being so involved you don't remember what you liked from time to time.
The MyBaby Soundspa On-The-Go is a budget-friendly choice with enough sounds to get the job done, but no other features like a night light. The buttons are intuitive and can be set quickly without frustration, which is huge if you are already dealing with a crying baby on your last nerve.
The VTech Myla The Monkey is a portable noise machine that includes lullabies and nature sounds with a white noise option. It comes with a two-level nightlight and two attachment features. This monkey is super cute, and little ones like the sweet face and glowing cheeks. We like the easy-to-push buttons and the simple, intuitive interface that we could sort out without using the instruction manual. One tester said, “I think I liked this option as much as my little one did.” It is also rechargeable, so there are no pesky batteries to change or keep on hand.
The only bummer we see for Myla is the lack of a wall plug. This decision in modern gadgets seems like the manufacturers' way of saving money. Still, it feels like an unfinished product as some people may not have extra plug adapters or modern USB plugs waiting for a cord on standby. One tester states, “I wasted more time than I have looking for a wall adapter that should have come with the monkey.” The Housbay White Noise Sound Machine plugs in and turns eight different colors that could be soothing for little ones. Otherwise, the Myla monkey is cute, easy to use, and has nice-sounding music and sounds with on-the-go possibilities consisting of a tail in the shape of a hook and a Velcro attachment.
The V-Tech portable Myla is a great option for staying at home or traveling about on errands or around the globe.
The MyBaby Soundspa On-The-Go is a portable sound machine that runs on batteries. One parent tester said, “I like not being tied down to an outlet.” This wallet-friendly option has a ring attachment and a simple user interface. The buttons are big and easy to use, including a helpful timer that can run for up to an hour before it shuts off. You can choose between 4 different sounds, including heartbeat, lullaby, white noise, and ocean sounds. “My baby loves the heartbeat setting.”// Said our main tester.
While this device is super easy to use, it is also reasonably simplistic, with few features and less impressive sounds. We think parents might go through many batteries and wish they were rechargeable, like our favorite portable choice. Our tester remarks, “While I do love a battery operation, I don't like that it isn't rechargeable and requires frequent battery changes or the purchase of rechargeable batteries.” The Housbay White Noise Sound Machine can be plugged in and save parents the battery hassles if they don't specifically need a travel-friendly choice where plugging in could be difficult. However, this inexpensive choice has much to love, and we think most babies will find something to like with this straightforward sound machine.
The MyBaby is a straightforward option that is easy to use and gets the job done without all the bells and whistles like projection or night light.
The Housbay White Noise Sound Machine is a ball-shaped noise maker that lights up with multiple colors (8!) and has so many lullabies and noises that you can listen to something different almost every night of the month. Our tester states, “I like that you can choose your favorite nightlight color and that there is a song, fan noise, or nature noise for everyone, including the ability to adjust the white noise pitch level!” It has three different timers or can run unchecked until you turn it off.
The user interface on the Housbay isn't user-friendly. We took a stab at it, and after much button pushing, we accepted whatever it landed on. We assume regular use and the instruction manual will help, but it doesn't seem necessary for something this simple to be this confusing. Our tester felt, “This is not the best choice for those who want to avoid reading instructions.” If your little one needs a kid-friendly design, the VTech Myla The Monkey is an adorable monkey that has a subtle glow and different sounds. Despite the need for some brushing up on your reading skills, we think this noisemaker is a good choice for babies, kids, and adults alike, with a setting suitable for most users.
The Housbay comes with a cord and wall plug, something we didn't see on all of the competition.
The Baby Shusher is a small portable noisemaker that emits a soft shushing sound akin to a rainmaker stick. This simple sound maker is travel-friendly and has shorter timer options. We think it would be good as a cue that sleeping time is happening, but it doesn't run all night, making it a good choice for parents who don't want or need an all-night solution. Our nanny tester also indicates, “It could be a good choice for more immediate needs to soothe a crying baby or a baby who is about to melt down.”
This sound machine has no variety; it makes one sound. You're out of luck if your little one doesn't have an affinity for the sound. The main tester felt, “I like having a variety of sounds because sometimes it takes a novel noise to capture and keep a baby's attention.”// Also, it only has two timers and no long-term play option, which could be a deal-breaker for those who like ambient noise all night to stay asleep. Alternatively, the Housbay White Noise Sound Machine has multiple different sounds and can run all night long. Overall, we think the Shusher has limitations, but it makes an excellent cue in a nighttime routine that could get little ones prepped for sleep and dreamland.
Nothing is simpler than the BabyShusher and its one sound two-timer selection with volume control design.
The Skip Hop Baby Sound Machine: Moonlight & Melodies has something for everyone, with various lullabies and nature sounds to choose from. It also features a dimmable nightlight in the owl's belly and a projection of the moon and stars on the ceiling. “The variety of soothing choices make it stand out in my mind,” reported our primary tester. The user interface is intuitive, and the buttons are easy to press. We like the fact that it has different timers or can run infinitely. Little ones like the owl design, but be forewarned, this design might increase demands to hold it as they get older, and it isn't intended for holding.
We didn't love the sounds on this machine. The lullabies have a tinny quality that can be harsh on the ears, and the heartbeat sound is not soothing, even if it isn't frightening like some of the competition. Also, the fabric on the owl wings over the speakers collects everything, from dog hair to dirt; ours were dirty within two days of unpacking the bird. Our tester felt, “It isn't great to have a baby product that seems to attract grime and fluff.” The sound and design on the VTech Myla The Monkey is better than the Skip Hop, in our tests. However, we like the concept of the Skip Hop and think some parents and babies will love it, but much like other all-in-one products, we don't think it does one thing exceptionally well and is mediocre at everything.
The Skip Hop has a USB-friendly cord and includes a wall plug giving you plug-in versatility and options.
The HoMedics Sound Spa harkens to the golden age of sound machines as they rose to popularity in the early 2000s. This machine has a button for everything, and better yet, they tell you at a glance what is happening and are super easy to use; no instructions necessary. Our tester showed their love of this item by saying, “I like the simple look and basic features and think adults will appreciate this straightforward choice, even if it is blah for a baby-centric product”.
This sound machine has no baby-specific features. While it has a few sounds and timer features, there are no lullabies, nightlights, or cute designs. While this alone isn't a deal-breaker, the sounds might be. The Housbay White Noise Sound Machine has better sounds, in our opinion, and we like the color changing. While a competitor's thunderstorm was so convincing, we could practically smell the rain, during testing, our testers felt that “this unit sounded like a new foley artist giving it his best shot for auditions for cartoon noisemaker.” In short, it can meet expectations if you don't compare it side-by-side with the competition. Unfortunately, for this Homedic option, we did.
The Homedic option comes with a cord and plug, unlike some of the competition that lacks a wall plug.
The LectroFan White Noise Machine is a basic white noise machine intended for a broader range of users than babies hoping for continuous sleep. This design makes it less baby-centric, as it only has white and fan noise selections. Our tester said, “I kind of like the simplicity of this choice and the lack of extraneous features.” This machine has a 60-minute timer or can be turned on for constant use, and the user interface is user-friendly.
Unfortunately, the tone of almost every sound option is not easy on the ears, and adults in our tests were somewhat agitated by the pitch of many of them. The sounds are overly stimulating, even for dogs in the testing area, and we suspect many babies will find them stimulating or at least not soothing. Also, there is nothing to indicate what sound you are playing, and while the unit will remember from time to time what you played last, it doesn't retain this information if you unplug it. Our tester said, “I hated that I couldn't tell what setting I was on. Even if I found one I liked, they are similar enough that it isn't obvious which setting it is.” With 20 sounds to choose from, finding the one you like could be challenging. We think this is a fine sound machine, but it wouldn't be our top pick for babies or kids, and we prefer the more straightforward and kid-centric VTech Myla The Monkey for babies and little ones who need some nighttime soothing.
The Lectrofan only offers white noise and fan sounds at a variety of pitches.
Credit: BabyGearLab Staff
The projection on the Skip Hop is better than the there projectors but it doesn't move or have other color options.
Credit: BabyGearLab Staff
How We Test Sound Machines
We considered more than 20 potential noise makers for kids before choosing products to test. We considered those specifically designed for little ones and others suitable for all family members. We used each product for at least two nights and assessed any features, from the variety of sound or musical options to timers or nightlights, if they were offered. Each tester reported their findings and feelings about which products offered the best quality, features, and ease of use. We considered feedback from little ones and parents alike and whether or not babies seemed soothed or relaxed due to the machine use.
The timer for SleepyMe is located on the bottom and one of the easier options to use.
Credit: BabyGearLab Staff
Why Trust GearLab
Since 2013, BabyGearLab has been testing baby gear and kids' products. We spent hours researching products before buying and using them side-by-side to find the absolute best options in each category for every kind of family. To find the best sound machines and white noise makers, we started by researching the top and most popular products available. We narrowed our selection to those we felt had the most potential to impress during testing. From there, we bought the top 10 competitors for testing. Senior Review Editor, Wendy Schmitz, mom of two, led the noisemaker team with a long history of using fans and other white noise generators for blissful sleep. Wendy and her children used each product in this review to give you the details to find the right one for your family, needs, and budget.
The plug for the Housbay is not a standard plug which could mean you need to toss the whole unit if you lose the plug.
Credit: BabyGearLab Staff
Analysis and Test Results
We purchased and used the most popular sound machines on the market, from truly baby-centric products to those with a more generalized purpose. We have the details you need to find the device that best meets your needs.
The Skip Hop User interface might look busy, but it is straightforward and you always know what you are getting without the need for toggling through sounds while your baby waits.
Credit: BabyGearLab Staff
Ease of Use
We thought these sound machines would all be relatively easy to use. While they all come with only a handful of buttons and icons that seem intuitive, most require toggling through all the options in a rotation, so you have to flip through the sounds multiple times to find what you want. You may not know what it is or how to get back to it should the sound change at any given point. Without any information on the device (which is true for most of them), you are flying blind, and we didn't think that was the best choice, even if it likely kept costs low.
The V-Tech Mila Monkey has super easy-to-use touch-friendly buttons and presses easily. The interface is user-friendly and straightforward, so you can skip the manual. Almost nothing is easier to use than the Baby Shusher as it has two twisting parts, one that gives you the timer and the other the volume. However, this simplicity also translates to limited features with one sound and only two timers, so if you want all night or a sound other than white noise, then forget it. The hardest products to use are the more adult varieties with very few buttons that you repeatedly press to switch between almost identical sounds, like the LectroFan White Noise Machine, which only has different pitches, none of which are pleasing to listen to long-term.
The Housbay has a friendly user interface and a glowing round body that makes it suitable for little ones who like a nightlight.
Credit: BabyGearLab Staff
Features
Everyone wants different features depending on their goals for using a sound machine. A night light to illuminate the darkness might feel like an excellent feature for those with younger infants, as it can help you see better when providing nighttime feeding. Or, your little one might relax quicker with a ceiling projector show. While the primary goal of a sound machine is to help create a peaceful environment conducive to sleep, that doesn't mean you need to settle for a dull white noise maker with no bells and whistles. We disliked the basic noise machine in this lineup, not for its lack of features but for the harsh pitches of its sounds.
The LectroFan has limited features, and none are genuinely baby-centric. This option has no nature or lullabies, with ten different pitches for white noise and fan sounds. Also, the sounds are somewhat painful to the ears depending on the settings, and a few even caused dog howling in our test area. Having no other features was just the nail in the coffin for this basic product.
The Zonpor user interface could use more buttons to avoid the frustration of toggling through options with limited buttons.
Credit: BabyGearLab Staff
Alternatively, the Skip Hop Owl has almost every feature a parent might want, including a nightlight you can dim, a ceiling projector with stars, lullabies, nature sounds, and timers. However, compared to the competition during testing, we felt this option didn't do anything very well. The sounds are sub-par, and the ceiling projection isn't strong enough to show more than fuzzy light blobs on the ceiling and walls.
Myla, the V-Tech device, is a portable night light and sound machine with lullabies, nature sounds, and a sleep timer.
Credit: BabyGearLab Staff
The V-Tech Myla Monkey is a favorite with multiple features. This cute little monkey comes with a nightlight and has various sound options, timers, and two attachment methods to keep it nearby. The sounds are relatively good, and we like that it is rechargeable, so you don't need to purchase batteries or keep them on hand continuously.
How to Pick the Best Sound Machine
Sound machines can be useful tools for soothing or entertaining little ones. Finding one that meets your needs and budget doesn't have to be a guessing game. Asking yourself a few questions about your goals can help you decide.
Why do you need one?
Asking yourself why you want a sound machine and what you hope it will accomplish is job one. Some parents are looking for something to drown out ambient noises, while others want something to help create calm or induce sleep. What your ultimate goals are will drive which options you are most attracted to. Some options are straightforward, with sounds that vary between white noise and waves and soft nature sounds. While others are more baby-centric and include lullabies and shushing sounds designed to mimic womb-like noise.
Other Features
If you want additional features over a simple noise maker, then this is the time to consider it. If your goal is more of a multi-purpose tool, then a baby-centric product might be more what you desire. Some of the options include nightlights and portability with rechargeable or changeable batteries for away-from-home use.
A familiar sound machine can help your little one fall asleep and stay asleep even in new environments.
Credit: BabyGearLab Staff
Conclusion
Selecting the best sound machine for your goals can be more challenging than you think, depending on your requirements. Should you choose one with nature sounds or lullabies? Both? Are the sounds natural? Does it include timers, or will it run all night for uninterrupted sleep? Luckily, we purchased and tested each option for you in this review. We believe there is a machine in this group for everyone in your family. Whether you are considering a portable device with an adorable monkey face or want nature sounds and nightlight, there is something for everyone in this lineup.
