REASONS TO BUY
Impressive materials
Great transparency
Excellent quality
REASONS TO AVOID
Expensive
Heavy
Avocado Organic Review
Eco-friendly and healthier materials combined with a quality design make it a great choice if your budget allows
Credit: Matt Lighthart
RELATED: The Best Crib Mattress
Our Verdict
The Avocado Organic is a decerning natural mattress we absolutely love. This impressive mattress offers a very transparent list of materials that includes GOLS-certified latex, GOTS-certified cotton and wool, and the innovative addition of coconut coir. We love that Avocado is committed to creating healthier mattresses and has created a high-quality, non-off-gassing option. We appreciate the dual-sided firmness for infants and toddlers and the use of wool batting to meet flammability standards without chemicals, making it a mattress you can feel good about. Unfortunately, this mattress is a beast and one of the heaviest and largest in the group. These factors influence how easily the sheets are changed and how well they fit in cribs. While we had no trouble with any test crib pairing with the Avocado, the over 25 lb heft of this option could be a deal breaker for some. Overall, we think if your budget can afford the higher price and your focus is natural materials, the Avocado is an excellent choice.
Compare to Similar Products
 This Product
Avocado Organic | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Awards |  Best Materials Crib Mattress |  Best Overall Crib Mattress | Best Washable Crib Mattress | High-Quality Innerspring Crib Mattress |  Best Bang for the Crib Mattress Buck |
| Price | $440 List | $289 List | $300 List $299.99 at Amazon | $330 List Check Price at Amazon | $200 List $199.00 at Amazon |
Overall Score  |
|||||
| Star Rating | |||||
| Bottom Line | If you have a bigger budget the materials and quality of this mattress justify the price | A nice quality mattress with healthier materials, but the weight and price could be prohibitive for some | A unique mattress that can be washed in the shower and fits in most cribs | Better quality option with innerspring and organic components, but the heft and price tag could make it a no-go depending on your goals | A polyester core mattress that is firm and lightweight with no polyurethane foam and a lower price |
| Rating Categories | Avocado Organic | My Green Emily Natural | Newton Original | Naturepedic Organic... | Babyletto Pure Core... |
| Materials (50%) | |||||
| Sheet Changing (30%) | |||||
| Crib Fit (20%) | |||||
| Specifications | Avocado Organic | My Green Emily Natural | Newton Original | Naturepedic Organic... | Babyletto Pure Core... |
| Weight | 25.6 lb | 19.4 lb | 13.8 lb | 21.1 lb | 12.0 lb |
| Height | 5.6 in | 6.1 in | 5.5 in | 6.8 in | 5.0 in |
| Length | 52.4 in | 52.4 in | 52.3 in | 52.3 in | 52.4 in |
| Width | 28.5 in | 28.0 in | 28.4 in | 28.1 in | 28.4 in |
| Mattress Tag Materials | Latex coir 57% Latex foam rubber pad 36% Wool fiber 7% Cover: Organic Cotton 100% |
Coconut Pad 80% Wool Batting 20% |
Polyethylene pad 74% Polyester fiber pad 16% Blended fiber felt 10% (Rayon 80% Polyester 20%) Cover: Polyester Fiber Pad 100% |
Fabric: GOTS certified organic cotton; Non-GMO Fill: GOTS certified organic cotton; Non-GMO PLA: from food-grade sugarcane; Non-GMO Support: food-grade polyethylene; Non-GMO Waterproofing: food-grade polyethylene from sugarcane; Non-GMO Innerspring: 150 coil count Secondary tag: All new material consisting of staple cotton batting 61% PLA - Polylactide batting 28% Polyethylene foam pad 11% |
Cover Top: 100% Organic staple cotton Cover batting: 100% Modacrylic Cover bottom: 100% Organic staple cotton Waterproof layer: 100% Polyethylene Core: 100% Polyester |
Our Analysis and Test Results
Avocado started in 2016 after a disappointing effort to find a healthier mattress showed a lot of greenwashing and what Avocado calls “gray area” in the industry. Finding a green, non-toxic, natural mattress proved to be a difficult venture. Avocado is designed in Hoboken and made in California. Their goal is to create ethical, sustainable mattresses that are natural and affordable.
We cut the Avocado Organic in half so you could see exactly what is inside, including the layers of cotton, wool, latex, and coconut.
Credit: Matt Lighthart
Materials
We really appreciated the transparent list of natural materials used in the Avocado, which is why it earned a high score in this metric.
The Avocado uses GOLS-certified latex, coconut coir, GOTS-certified organic cotton, and organic wool. The details they provide are like nothing we've ever seen, and it is clear they have set out to create a mattress they'd want for their own babies. The mattress tag states:
The Avocado is a straightforward mattress with useful layers of GOTS and GOLS certified materials that are natural and do not contain VOCs.
Credit: Matt Lighthart
Cover- 100% GOTS Organic Certified Stretch Cotton
Border- 100% GOTS Organic Certified Stretch Cotton
Closing Tape- Natural GOTS Organic Certified Cotton Tape (Green)
INFANT SIDELayer 1- 100% GOTS organic certified Needle Punch Wool - Needle punched to provide extra breathability
Layer 2- 100% GOTS organic certified Cotton Jersey
Layer 3- 3" GOLS organic certified Coconut Pad- D80- Firm (we use D65 on the very top of our standard green mattress, whereas the Coconut Pad we use on the infant side would rate D80 in comparison - scale of 1-100 w/100 being the firmest)
The Avocado infant side includes a coconut coir layer that is firmer than the toddler side, which has thinner coconut over softer latex.
Credit: Matt Lighthart
TODDLER SIDE
Layer 1- 100% GOTS organic certified Needle Punch Wool- Needle punched to provide extra breathability
Layer 2- 100% GOTS-certified Jersey Cotton
Layer 3- 2"100% Organic Dunlop Latex- D75/ ILD 20-25-Medium - provide support/give for toddlers
Layer 4- 0.5" Coconut Pad
Little ones are sure to love sleeping on the Avocado Organic.
Credit: Matt Lighthart
Also, it is worth stating that the company takes strides to produce and assemble the materials in as environmentally friendly way as possible, stating that they are a Certified-B Corporation, they are in the 1% for the Planet® Pinnacle Award winner, have been climate neutral since 2019, and are working toward zero waste manufacturing.
The Avocado is one of the hardest options to change sheets with, thanks to its heavy weight and larger size.
Credit: Matt Lighthart
Sheet Changing
The Avocado did not score well in our tests for sheet changes.
The Avocado weighs 25.6 lbs, making it the heaviest option in the group, with the closest competitor weighing almost 4 lbs less. Thanks to the latex core layer for the toddler side, this beast of a mattress is harder to lift.
The firmer and more detailed edges of the Avocado create a snugger fit in most cribs than most of the mattresses we tested.
Credit: Matt Lighthart
It is also a high-quality option with firm edges and a snug fit, so lifting it and holding it up to put a new sheet on could be a challenge for petite parents or when the mattress platform is lower.
The Avocado is the heaviest mattress and one of the group's largest options.
Credit: Matt Lighthart
Crib Fit
The Avocado struggled in some of our test cribs, earning a lower score than most in this metric.
As one tester put it, “The fit is really tight, and I think it's like wrestling an alligator to get it out of the crib.” While the mattress itself didn't measure that much bigger than the average option, it was still a snug fit in some of our cribs.
When you look in the upper left-hand corner, you can see that the Avocado is almost too big for this crib.
Credit: Matt Lighthart
While it fits in all of them, it was so tight in a couple of options that we think it would be frustrating to pair the two over time. We recommend testing the mattress with your chosen crib before the return window has passed.
The Avocado Organic offers a natural sleep surface that doesn't off gas to create a healthier sleeping space.
Credit: Matt Lighthart
Should You Buy the Avocado Organic?
The Avocado Organic is a really cool mattress if your budget is big enough. We love that this dual-sided mattress uses GOLS-certified latex and coconut coir to create two different firmness levels for growing babies. We also like the organic wool batting and cotton cover, which combine to create one of the most natural and transparent mattresses we've ever seen. We'd recommend this option to families concerned with materials and avoiding VOCs who have a budget big enough to bring this one home.
What Other Crib Mattresses Should You Consider?
The Avocado is expensive and heavy; either factor could make it a deal breaker for some families. If you don't mind man-made materials, the Babyletto Pure Core with Dry Waterproof Cover is half the weight of the Avocado and incorporates a waterproof cover. It is also less expensive and can save you money. Alternatively, if you want to stay on the more natural side, the My Green Mattress Emily Natural uses an innerspring structure with coconut coir and wool batter similar to the Avocado, coming in almost 6 lbs lighter, with a lower price.
Manufacturer Video
—Wendy Schmitz
You Might Also Like
