Compare Nipple Creams Compare Products Compare select up to 5 products to compare Score Product Price 83 Weleda Nipple BalmBest Overall Nipple Balm $15 70 Honest Calm Your Nip BalmFavorite Lanolin-free Nipple Balm $15 65 Lansinoh LanolinBest Nipple Cream on a Budget $22 61 Bamboobies BoobeaseBest Organic Nipple Balm $10 45 Dr. Bronner's Organic Magic Balm $20 38 Earth Mama Natural Nipple Butter $16 36 Motherlove Nipple Cream $16